As 400,000 workers near retirement, the report signals a widening "relevance gap," calling on insurers to modernize work culture, connect with new talent, and rebuild trust
NEW YORK, Oct. 29, 2025 -- Cake & Arrow, an experience design and product innovation agency for the insurance industry, published a new report revealing a growing relevance gap between Gen Z's expectations of work and what the insurance industry represents.
The report, Why Gen Z is Ambivalent About Working in Insurance found that 79% of Gen Z have never considered working in insurance, and nearly half (49%) say they have no interest in doing so, despite 55% still viewing the industry positively. The findings point to a perception paradox among young professionals who recognize the value of insurance careers but struggle to see a place for themselves within the industry.
The disconnect comes at a pivotal moment, as 400,000 insurance workers are projected to retire by 2026, leaving insurers racing to attract new talent just as Gen Z is redefining what career stability means. The report emphasizes that insurers can bridge this gap not through better recruiting, but by engaging directly with Gen Z and connecting the industry's strengths—stability, purpose, and impact—with what young professionals value most: flexibility, modern culture, and meaningful work.
"Insurance has many of the qualities Gen Z is looking for in a career, but they don't see it that way," said Josh Levine, CEO and founder of Cake & Arrow. "When 11 of 12 people in our study say insurance companies will do whatever they can to deny claims, it exposes a trust gap—but also an opportunity to rebuild purpose. Insurance exists to protect people in moments of uncertainty, and that's a mission Gen Z can rally around. The opportunity now is to engage this generation in reimagining the industry from the inside out—restoring trust and shaping insurance into a platform for impact and innovation."
Based on a national survey of more than 500 Gen Z respondents and in-depth qualitative interviews, the research found that the next generation:
- Values financial stability (66%) but expects a modern, adaptable work culture
- Wants flexibility (39%) and strong work-life balance (41%)
- Seeks values-driven employers (41%) but remains skeptical of industry ethics
While Gen Z is pragmatic about money, they are wary of outdated systems. Many described insurance careers as boring (67%) or overly corporate, with only 16% expressing interest in working for large organizations.
Despite this skepticism, the report identifies clear opportunities for insurers to reposition themselves as future-ready employers. It encourages leaders to move beyond assumptions and collaborate directly with Gen Z through open dialogue, transparent communication, and shared problem-solving, to align the industry's promise of stability and purpose with modern expectations of flexibility and impact.
Why Gen Z Is Ambivalent About Working in Insurance is part of Cake & Arrow's ongoing research into generational attitudes shaping the future of work, design, and financial services. The findings are based on a nationwide survey of 519 Gen Z respondents, ages 18-28, representing a diverse mix of income levels, education, and regions across the United States, supplemented by 12 in-depth qualitative interviews exploring attitudes towards work, stability, and the insurance industry.
Click here to download the report. To learn more about Cake & Arrow, visit https://cakeandarrow.com/.
About Cake & Arrow
Cake & Arrow is an experience design and product innovation agency that works exclusively with the insurance and financial service industries. We believe empathy sparks opportunity. Our human-centered design approach helps carriers, distributors, and insurtechs create transformative digital experiences that drive results. Since 2002, Cake & Arrow has partnered with leading insurance and finance companies, including MetLife, Aflac, Citigroup, Travelers, Chubb, Aon, and The General.
This News is brought to you by Qube Mark, your trusted source for the latest updates and insights in marketing technology. Stay tuned for more groundbreaking innovations in the world of technology.
